Skip to main content

Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations theory: An Imperialist Viewpoint



Since the atrocities in New York, Washington and Pennsylvania on September 11, 2001, Islam and Muslims have become the main subject matter of discussion throughout the world. The threat for the West is emerging not from ideology rather from religion, which, has always, had a reputation of being a violent faith. Since then, the understanding of Islam has become paramount to justify the effects that it has to the global affairs.

Samuel P. Huntington’s Clash of Civilisation theory has become vital to analyse the pattern of global conflicts, which, have been transformed from ideology to religion. The collapse of communism in the Soviet Union and the dismantling of Eastern bloc left a vacuum of parties/powers in international conflicts. Since then, the West revived the old rivalries between Christianity and Eastern faiths especially emphasising Islam as a major opponent to uphold the beliefs of Western civilisations.

The argument that Huntington put forward in his theory obviously is one tainted by Western perspectives. There is no tangible consideration given to Eastern values, which are based on religion. The refutable explanations given in his articles are clearly undermining the basic concept of the Eastern faiths especially Islam. The negative picture, which has been portrayed, not only enhances the very nature of views on Islam but rather damaging the basic elements that the faith emphasises - the importance of upholding peace and tolerance.

The view Huntington has of Islam and Muslims is highly questionable. He wants the West to know the ‘enemy’ in order to safeguard the interests of the West on global affairs. The fear that he has further can be observed in his argument that Islam and Confucianism will collaborate together and eventually go against the West in future.

These negative projections made by international news agencies have a huge impact on the face of Islam globally. Islam is seen as a violent, fanatical, uncivilised and oppressed biased religion throughout the world and this has been preached and orchestrated by the western media. This is obviously a collective and well devised plan of the West with the intention of undermining Islam and Muslims so that the West can have absolute control of their movements and interests. History has taught the West that if they fail to suppress others, in this case Muslims, the consequents on the West is that they will be conquered and dominated.

The West views the migration of immigrants all over the world particularly from Muslim countries to Europe and North America as an invasion. The emergence of right wing parties gaining popularity throughout Europe in the recent general election has confirmed fears of this incursion. In the Netherlands, the emergence of the Pim Foutryn Party, which, imposed restrictions on immigrants and in France the interest that Jean-Marie Le Pen got on his anti-immigrant platform significantly demonstrated the change of heart of the West on the view of immigrants especially Muslims.


This is a significant shift of policy on Muslims countries by the West since the collapse of Communism. The September 11th attacks have affirmed the fears and reinforced the deep-seated aggression of the West to depress and harm Muslims throughout the world.

The rivalry and continuous aggression of West towards Islam and Muslims will not benefit the world as a whole. The massacre of Jenin in Palestine and the continuous instability in the Middle East has built up the mistrust of Muslims towards West. The War on Terrorism, the War against Iraq and Afghanistan has left a huge negative impact on Muslims worldwide. Further the statement embarked by the current US President recently on war on terrorism (‘either you are with us or otherwise) had demonstrated to the world that Muslims throughout the world have been forced to take and make a stand. This sort of situation wills to further demoralise the faith that Muslims have on the current establishment. Just as the late Pope John Paul II had successfully bridged the gap between Muslims, Christians and Jews in one understanding, there is a bright future to look forward to rather going back to the primitive theory of Huntington. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Constitution of Malaysia: An Introduction Part 5

7 (1) No person shall be punished for an act or omission which was not punishable by law when it was done or made, and no person shall suffer greater punishment for an offence than was prescribed by law at the time it was committed. (2) A person who has been acquitted or convicted of an offence shall not be tried again for the same offence except where the conviction or acquittal has been quashed and a retrial ordered by a court superior to that by which he was acquitted or convicted.

Brexit: A lesson for Malaysians

Yesterday, Britons through a referendum made a decision to leave European Union. The ruling Conservative Party divided on this referendum and David Cameron in favour of ‘Remain’ was defeated outright. Even though he is disagreed with the decision of Britons, he announced that he is resigning from his premiership in respect of people’s decision. We can expect in a mature democracy country like United Kingdom this is vastly anticipated to be transpired.   A few days ago, the current Chief Commissioner of Malaysian Anti-Corruption of Commission made a statement that he is stepping down from his position and there are some rumours indicating that a few prominent officers from the said Commission will either resign or retire. It’s very eccentric news for Malaysians as it will have a profound impact on bribery and corruption issues in Malaysia as a whole. Recently, the results of two by elections were won by Barisan Nasional, the ruling party of Malaysia. Many promises had been...

Two Tales, Two Leaders - PART 1

Man has dual nature; he is both his own person and a member of his country. On the one hand, the law must protect the individual from the injustices of the multitude.  History has shown how individuals fall prey to mass perversity, their crime being simply a refusal to conform to the beliefs and prejudices of the majority. Anwar Ibrahim, The Asian Renaissance, 1997., Page 63. The value system and ethical code therefore determine the success or failure of corrective measures. If the value system is wrong, corrective measures will not be productive or will be only slightly productive. When the value system motivates, very little corrective measures are needed. Dr. Mahathir bin Mohamad, The Malay Dilemma, 1970., Pages 172-173. Introduction Malaysia is our motherland. We love our country. This country has so much of wealth. Even though, Malaysia has agonized considerably in past three decades because of the malpractices of the corrupted characters but she is never fail t...