Skip to main content

Rajeshvari and Article 5 of the Federal Constitution 1957

Article 5. Liberty of the person.

(1) No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty save in accordance with law.

(2) Where complaint is made to a High Court or any judge thereof that a person is being unlawfully detained the court shall inquire into the complaint and, unless satisfied that the detention is lawful, shall order him to be produced before the court and release him.

(3) Where a person is arrested he shall be informed as soon as may be of the grounds of his arrest and shall be allowed to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of his choice.

(4) Where a person is arrested and not released he shall without unreasonable delay, and in any case within twenty-four hours (excluding the time of any necessary journey) be produced before a magistrate and shall not be further detained in custody without the magistrate's authority:

Provided that this Clause shall not apply to the arrest or detention of any person under the existing law relating to restricted residence, and all the provisions of this Clause shall be deemed to have been an integral part of this Article as from Merdeka Day:

Provided further that in its application to a person, other than a citizen, who is arrested or detained under the law relating to immigration, this Clause shall be read as if there were substituted for the words "without unreasonable delay, and in any case within twenty-four hours (excluding the time of any necessary journey)" the words "within fourteen days":

And provided further that in the case of an arrest for an offence which is triable by a Syariah court, references in this Clause to a magistrate shall be construed as including references to a judge of a Syariah court.

(5) Clauses (3) and (4) do not apply to an enemy alien.

_________________________________________________________
Suhakam raps Immigration
Source:

PETALING JAYA: The Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) has lambasted the Immigration Department for allowing a citizen to be held in an Immigration depot for 11 months.
Commissioner Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria said that what had happened to 22-year-old M. Rajeshvari was a great travesty.

The Star reported yesterday that Rajeshvari spent an agonising 11 months at the Lenggeng Immigration depot for illegals because she could not remember her identity card number when police checked her at a coffee shop in the capital and that she was not fluent in Bahasa Malaysia.

She was also six months’ pregnant at the time and gave birth to a boy while in detention.

Dr Denison said: “One should get to the root of how the verification was done. Holding a citizen like that is a violation of human rights.

“If language was a problem, they should have had an interpreter to get to the bottom of it. If it were not for the intervention of the clinic and a voluntary organisation, she would still be in there.

He noted that there could be various reasons for her inability to communicate, adding that Rajeshvari may have been terrified, not of sound mind or not confident.

“What safeguards are there? How can such a thing be avoided?” Dr Denison said, adding the Immigration Department must be held accountable and that an apology was not enough.

The Star received countless calls from members of the public and other interested parties about Rajeshvari's plight, some offering jobs and help.

Women’s Aid Organisation executive director Ivy Josiah said the Home Ministry had to review the entire raiding and detention mechanism as it was in danger of violating human rights.
“There has to be a mechanism for such detained people to seek redress and ensure that this kind of mistake never happens again.

“When you detain people, you take away their freedom. You must make sure they have regular access to lawyers, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and Suhakam,” Josiah said.

However, Immigration Department enforcement chief Datuk Ishak Mohamed said that the burden of proof of citizenship was on the person suspected of being an illegal immigrant.

“The new Criminal Procedure Code also allows the suspect to make phone calls to anyone who can help,” he said, pointing out that the police had picked her up, not Immigration officials.

“But, please, don’t tell me that after 22 years, you cannot speak Bahasa Malaysia? You mean she would not know how to sing Negaraku either?” he added.

Rajeshvari was released from the depot in Seremban on Friday after Malaysian Indian Youth Council vice-president Andrew Raju got her birth certificate details from her primary school in Kampar.

Comments:
Is there any infringements of fundamental human rights on Rajeshvari?

The justification given by the authority does it comply with Article 5 of our Federal Constitution?

What is the duty of the authority when they detained a person who is suspected as an illegal immigrant?

The basic search that they have to do is to determine whether that particular person is actually an illegal immigrant not to transfer the burden of proof to the suspect expecting the suspect to tell the truth.

In this case, Rajeshvari's situation is pitiful and clear violation of human right. Is sinful to the authority to detain a person who cannot converse in Bahasa and give a clear identity to prove that she is a Malaysian.

How about the special children, illiterate and unsound mind persons? Do the authority have the clear guidelines and mechanisms to determine the identity of Malaysians and illegal immigrants?

What we are expecting from the authority to use commonsenses and have a proper guidelines not to penalise the innocent persons like Rajeshvari and her new born child.

Rajeshvari is only 22 years old and we do not know what had triggered her. What we can do as the caring Malaysians, to assist her to overcome this difficult situation. We need to think about the stigma that she and the baby have to carry throughout their life. It's sad to happen. Very sad.

We hope the authority will handle this kind situation very delicately in near future to avoid any violations of human rights under Article 5 of the Federal Constitution.

May god bless Rajeshvari and her child always!

Comments

Anonymous said…
There are hundred and thousands of illegal Indons moving freely but there is no action. Why abusing Indian ?
Anonymous said…
We are treated as imigriants not the indon's. What rubbish is this!
Anonymous said…
We are living as a 3rd class citizen with no freedom of speach. Negara ku is not an issue translater is.
the DG of immigration in his most intellectual statement said that rajeshvary was wrong in that sense being malaysian she cannot speak malay, let me ask you, you been malaysian for long time can u speak chiness, indian, punjabi or iban??

Being stupid is one thing but being stupid and being a DG of very important organizations is another thing!!!\

Go down in the field and see ur own eye what is is the problem that many ordinary plp having. a bit of human right concern would have free the poor women..but !!
Anonymous said…
about the enemy alien, can u explain further to me..bcoz i cant understand it properly..thanks

Popular posts from this blog

Two Tales, Two Leaders - PART 1

Man has dual nature; he is both his own person and a member of his country. On the one hand, the law must protect the individual from the injustices of the multitude.  History has shown how individuals fall prey to mass perversity, their crime being simply a refusal to conform to the beliefs and prejudices of the majority. Anwar Ibrahim, The Asian Renaissance, 1997., Page 63. The value system and ethical code therefore determine the success or failure of corrective measures. If the value system is wrong, corrective measures will not be productive or will be only slightly productive. When the value system motivates, very little corrective measures are needed. Dr. Mahathir bin Mohamad, The Malay Dilemma, 1970., Pages 172-173. Introduction Malaysia is our motherland. We love our country. This country has so much of wealth. Even though, Malaysia has agonized considerably in past three decades because of the malpractices of the corrupted characters but she is never fail t...

Brexit: A lesson for Malaysians

Yesterday, Britons through a referendum made a decision to leave European Union. The ruling Conservative Party divided on this referendum and David Cameron in favour of ‘Remain’ was defeated outright. Even though he is disagreed with the decision of Britons, he announced that he is resigning from his premiership in respect of people’s decision. We can expect in a mature democracy country like United Kingdom this is vastly anticipated to be transpired.   A few days ago, the current Chief Commissioner of Malaysian Anti-Corruption of Commission made a statement that he is stepping down from his position and there are some rumours indicating that a few prominent officers from the said Commission will either resign or retire. It’s very eccentric news for Malaysians as it will have a profound impact on bribery and corruption issues in Malaysia as a whole. Recently, the results of two by elections were won by Barisan Nasional, the ruling party of Malaysia. Many promises had been...

An Open Letter to Ayahanda Tun - PART 3

For me, to say I want to go to sleep and retire and prepare for my afterlife, I think that is very selfish. Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, The Straits Times – 22 January 2017. This statement is the reflection of ayahanda Tun’s true character. For many of us, he is father of this nation. His love for this nation is unprecedented. Even though he was retired in 2003 but made a comeback in 2018 as the seventh Prime Minster of Malaysia at the age of 93 years. He made a history. At this twilight age, most people would have a ‘quite’ life but not ayahanda.   The biggest question is why ayahanda had to return to active in politics at this age to ‘save’ Malaysia. What are the factors which have triggered him to take such a drastic decision? At that time, Malaysia’s reputation was at the stake because of the kleptocratic regime. In addition, the economic, social and political factors had triggered him to make a comeback. But, the main focal point of his return is the damaged r...