Skip to main content

Criminologist: Malaysia a sinful place to IS?

By Nawar Firdaws

KUALA LUMPUR: Is Malaysia a “place of sin” in the eyes of Islamic State (IS) militants?
An expert in terrorism studies, R Paneir Selvam, certainly thinks so.
Speaking to FMT, Paneir said despite Malaysia being a Muslim country, the terror group was still able to convince a large number of its followers that Malaysia, too, had deviated from the true Islamic teachings.
“This is the IS propaganda — spreading the message that Malaysia is akin to a place of sin.
“They have successfully convinced some into believing that the country’s failure to fulfil or live up to their expectations, especially in the various aspects of religion, qualifies it as a place of sin and hence should not be spared from their attacks.”
The Association of Legal and Policy Researchers’ chairman said although the government had done its best to counter IS ideologies, some still fall for the militants’ “holier than thou” attitude.
“What Malaysian IS members fail to recognise is that the country has been very accepting and accommodating when it comes to the practice of Islam.
“Those who joined IS are the ones who do not have an in-depth understanding of the religion, making them easier to influence, especially by those who appear to be well versed in the Quran.
“IS dangles the carrot of martyrdom and a promise to have the sins of their recruits wiped clean. And that is why it particularly appeals to troubled youth.”
He added that the danger of the Syria and Iraq-based group was the fact that unlike al-Qaeda, IS is not exactly structured.
“Just a small hint, or a message from the leaders, and the members will immediately launch an attack.
“They are also driven by the call of duty to act on behalf of their fellow Muslim brothers and sisters killed elsewhere.”
To be a step ahead of the group, which has taken countless lives, Paneir said the authorities had to go beyond conventional methods and look to forming a team of experts comprising those with diverse backgrounds.
“You can’t rely solely on experts on the topic of Islam. We need to set up a team of experts in various disciplines, religions and expertise, similar to the strategy employed by the United States’ FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigation) to counter terrorism.
“This is necessary to allow a more complete picture and understanding of the problem, so that it can come up with an ‘out of the box’ solution,” said the lecturer at Help University.
Last month, a video published by this terror group was released online, featuring the first known Malaysian IS fighter in Syria, Mohd Rafi Udin, who urged IS supporters here to stage independent attacks.
The call was followed by a grenade attack on the Movida bar in Puchong.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Smart Security, Free Society: Malaysia’s Data Dilemma

In today’s digitally driven world, national security is no longer confined to borders or traditional threats. Cyberattacks, disinformation campaigns, and asymmetric warfare have become the new frontiers of conflict. Malaysia, strategically located in Southeast Asia and increasingly exposed to regional tensions and internal vulnerabilities, must strengthen its security apparatus. However, doing so must not come at the cost of civil liberties. Malaysia can enhance its security strategy by leveraging insights from advanced data platforms like those pioneered by Palantir Technologies, while maintaining strong democratic oversight to safeguard the fundamental freedoms protected by the Federal Constitution. Palantir Technologies, a U.S.-based company, gained prominence in the aftermath of the September 11 attacks. Its core software, Gotham, was designed to integrate fragmented intelligence and provide real-time, actionable insights to military and intelligence agencies. Over the years,...

Syringe Attacks in Malaysia and France: Random Violence or Terrorism? - Part 3

The syringe attack on the 12-year-old son of Pandan MP and former Economy Minister, Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli, has shaken Malaysia. What initially appeared as a rare and bizarre incident now echoes a disturbing pattern witnessed abroad, notably in France. In June 2025, during the Fête de la Musique festival, over 145 people across France reported being pricked with syringes in crowded public areas. In both cases, the weapon of fear was not a gun or bomb but a syringe. When viewed together, the Rafizi incident and the mass needle attacks in France reveal an alarming global trend of unconventional, psychological violence that leaves behind not just physical uncertainty but emotional trauma. The question we must now ask is: are these acts simply random criminality, or should they be treated with the gravity of terrorist attacks? A Pattern Beyond Borders In France, the attacks spanned multiple cities, with 13 confirmed cases in Paris alone. Victims included women, men, and even min...

Constitution of Malaysia: An Introduction Part 5

7 (1) No person shall be punished for an act or omission which was not punishable by law when it was done or made, and no person shall suffer greater punishment for an offence than was prescribed by law at the time it was committed. (2) A person who has been acquitted or convicted of an offence shall not be tried again for the same offence except where the conviction or acquittal has been quashed and a retrial ordered by a court superior to that by which he was acquitted or convicted.